The name, announced on April 29, honors the extraordinary examples of Willard "Bill" Carmel '52 and George Boyer '51, who shared a devotion to the success of generations of 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ students.
In business and in life, Baldwin Wallace University graduates Willard "Bill" Carmel '52 and George Boyer '51 found the freedom to soar.
"These
two
distinguished
alumni
led
parallel
and
intersecting
lives
of
great
purpose
-
building
a
legacy
of
exceptional
career
achievement,
deep
personal
fulfillment
and
enduring
community
impact,"
said
91Ώμ»ξΑΦ
President
Bob
Helmer.
Now, both men are honored in the new name for 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ's business school: the Baldwin Wallace University Carmel Boyer School of Business, unveiled at a celebration on Friday, April 29.
The name celebrates a shared devotion to the success of generations of 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ students that remained rock solid even as thriving finance careers anchored one in Northeast Ohio and took the other to New York City.
Friends for 70 years, Carmel and Boyer connected while studying business at Baldwin Wallace in the late 1940s and early '50s.
Both pride themselves on being students of legendary 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ business professor Jacob O. Kamm '40 and attribute the seeds of their career success to his influence. It is fitting that the Carmel Boyer School of Business is housed in 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ's Kamm Hall, which bears their college mentor's name.
"Jake was responsible for so many of us who found success in financial services," Boyer shared. "He stimulated our minds. We had an investment club, and he instilled in us the idea of careful research and patience in investing."
Carmel called Kamm "inspiring," and both men recalled their professor taking them to visit C-suites around the region. "We would get all dressed up, tuck our Wall Street Journals under our arms and go downtown," Carmel remembers.
Carmel and Boyer both went on from college to achieve extraordinary business success in their careers. Carmel rose to be CEO of the Cleveland-based investment company McDonald & Company Securities; Boyer was a partner in the Wall Street firm Goldman Sachs.
But it was their roles as trustees of their alma mater that made them men of consequence in the history of 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ.
"With nearly 100 years of combined service on the 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ Board of Trustees, Bill and George paid their success forward to generations of 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ students who came after them, giving time, talent and treasure to 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ," notes 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ Board Chair Agnes Dover. "Their impact is extraordinary."
"As business leaders and trustees, both commanded respect," said Pat Dunlavy '71, who served as a trustee before taking on the role of VP for Philanthropy. "When they spoke, all trustees listened closely. Many of us who served with them consider both men to be mentors and friends."
Carmel
chaired
the
91Ώμ»ξΑΦ
Trustees
for
five
years
and
led
three
capital
campaigns.
Former
91Ώμ»ξΑΦ
President
Neal
Malicky
wrote
in
his
memoir
that
Carmel
was
a
partner
in
91Ώμ»ξΑΦ's
rebound
from
a
financial
slump
during
his
time
as
president.
Malicky also approached Boyer about serving as board chair, but Boyer suggested his talents would best be leveraged as chair of the Investment Committee instead.
And so, Boyer (and Carmel, too) spent years providing leadership for the management of 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ's endowment, each applying their specialized financial acumen - Boyer on the equity side of the fund, Carmel on the fixed income side.
"They shouldered that significant burden of managing and growing the endowment for free, saving the University significant sums in investment fees," said Dick Fletcher '70, MBA '76, a recently retired longtime senior officer of 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ. "George used to say the first thing he did in the morning was check the value of the 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ portfolio."
Such savvy and dedicated stewardship helped the endowment grow by leaps and bounds. In fact, 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ's investment return was in the top five percent of all colleges and universities in the nation for a number of years.
Malicky recalled, "The leadership of George Boyer, Bill Carmel and other members of the Investment Committee was absolutely essential to such growth. It did and will bring long-term benefit to Baldwin Wallace."
Today, 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ's endowment is a vital source of institutional stability and scholarship support for students.
Mentorship was another key value for each man as they developed, motivated and challenged young business talent the way they were taught and mentored as promising young 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ business students.
Carmel often recruited talent from 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ and found his eventual successor in a 20-year-old 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ intern he hired: Bill Summers '72.
"Bill [Carmel] became my mentor, coach and advocate," Summers recalls. "He was the equivalent of my business 'father,' and when my dad died in 1989, he became like an actual father to me."
Mentorship matters. Following Carmel's retirement, Summers was elevated to president of McDonald & Company and quickly added the title of CEO.
Looking back, both Carmel and Boyer considered the range of values that undergirded their fulfilling careers and lives.
Carmel believes managers must remember that business is people-powered. "When people get into positions of power, I don't think you can be successful unless you really like people. If you're going to be in any management position, you have to like people and treat them the way you would want to be treated."
He also urges students today to "work hard and love what you do."
"Everybody is born with their own specific talents and advantages. You just have to find what you're good at. Find the right job and fall in love with what you do. From day one, I woke up ready and eager to get to work."
Boyer's advice to future business students, dispensed in a separate conversation, mirrors his longtime friend's. "Work hard, be charitable and have civility."
Boyer adds, "It's also important in life to be charitable and honorable. Like that line at the end of the movie 'Saving Private Ryan' says, 'Be a good person.'"
"Future 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ business students should know that their school is named for two of the finest businesspeople in investment banking, and they did it with class and dignity," Summers notes.
"There could not be more loyal, devoted, successful, classy, generous and kind businesspeople that ever walked the halls of 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ," Summers concludes. "How talented they were, yet humble; confident, hard-working and demanding, but fair and kind; generous but not boastful. There are no finer men in every respect than these two."
Carmel and Boyer embody what it means to be a "success:" pursuing their dreams with integrity, purpose and drive and finding the freedom to soar - in business and in life.
Find out more in this story about Bill Carmel's extraordinary life and career.
Read more in this piece on George Boyer's extraordinary life and career.
Watch the video below, narrated by Bill Summers '72, to trace the intersecting lives, careers and impact on 91Ώμ»ξΑΦ's School of Business by Jacob O. Kamm, Bill Carmel and George Boyer.